Radicals, Reformers and Diversity of Thought in the Civil Rights Movement

When one looks at the great social movements that have changed America for the better, one of the things that becomes apparent is the diversity of viewpoints that are found among the various activists fighting for social change. Some activists are reformers who work within the political system to try to change laws and to elect political leaders who are sympathetic to their just cause. Some activists are more radical, who try to organize the marginalized and disenfranchised to empower them and bypass the existing political institutions to create more egalitarian systems of achieving justice. These radicals and reformers frequently disagree in their tactics and philosophies. Social change, though, is not possible without both radicals and reformers. A great example of this can be found in the civil rights movement.

Throughout the history of the civil rights movement for African Americans, the leaders held diverse viewpoints and they frequently clashed. Think of the names of the various leaders, individuals like Pauli Murray, Ella Baker, Martin Luther King Jr., Bayard Rustin, Malcolm X, Dorothy Height, Stokeley Carmichael, Thurgood Marshall, Angela Davis. All of these people were working for full freedom and equality for African Americans, yet all had very different philosophies and tactics. Some activists, like Thurgood Marshall and Clarence Jones were lawyers that worked to break down legal barriers to equal rights for African Americans. Activists from the Christian tradition, like Martin Luther King Jr., Ralph Abernathy, Pauli Murray, and James Farmer, used nonviolent civil disobedience campaigns to bring out the injustices for the whole country to see and to act upon. Malcolm X, and later the Black Panther Party, thought that the African American community must fight for equal rights by any means necessary, that it cannot limit itself to nonviolent means if the oppressors are using violent means.

Within these diverse viewpoints were many clashes and debates. Martin Luther King Jr.’s nonviolent methods were questioned by Malcolm X and later Stokley Carmichael. Bayard Rustin’s conviction that the African American community must join in a broad coalition with unions and progressive churches clashed with the Black Panther ideology that the African American community must look inward and learn to help themselves. Leaders who wanted the movement to focus on legal and political gains clashed with activists who wanted the movement to focus on street protests and mass demonstrations. These differences tactics and philosophies appealed to different segments of the African American population, and it gave the civil rights movement a broader base of participants than if everyone had to follow one philosophy and one set of tactics.

A grassroots social movement does not depend on everyone in the movement being in agreement on philosophy. Reformers need radicals because the radicals are the ones who are out in the streets, organizing protests and making the arguments that slowly change public opinion to their cause. Radicals have historically been the canaries in the mine, who are the first to point out the problems of society before the mainstream society is aware that there is any problems. The radical’s constant prodding for change and the outside pressure that radicals put on the political system helps give the reformer something that they can bargain with to give their reforms some teeth. Radicals make reformers accountable so that reformers do not compromise too much and constantly prod reformers for ever stronger actions.

Radicals need reformers because it is the reformers who work within the political system and make the necessary compromises to enact legislation that addresses the problems that the radicals are fighting. Reformers frame the arguments for change in a way that persuades moderates to join in their cause. Reformers allow middle-of-the-road people to participate who may be scared of the radical’s ideology but are sympathetic to the radical’s cause. Without the reformers bringing in the mainstream audience to the social movement, the radicals’ messsage winds up marginalized and radicals end up preaching to the choir.

Radicals and reformers frequently argue with each other about tactics and philosophy. Whether they like it or not, though, significant social change cannot happen without both of them working for a common goal. Radicals and reformers act as a check and balance to the others worst weaknesses and one group can reach out to segments of the population that the other group cannot reach.

This diversity is why the civil rights movement had the participation of such a broad reach of people. Students, teachers, lawyers, housewives, wealthy patrons, celebrities, blue-collar workers, artists and young professionals all took part. This diversity of philosophies that we see in the civil rights movement can also be seen in the feminist movement, the LGBT movement, the labor movement and almost all other social movements. The most successful grassroots movements are those that have the broadest participation of different types of people. Such a broad coalition of people insures that justice is fought for in several fronts.

Here are some famous African American speeches and articles that represent different philosophies within the African American civil rights movement.

The Letter From A Birmingham Jail was written by Martin Luther King Jr. on April 16, 1963. In this letter, King gave a defense on nonviolent civil disobedience as a means for the oppressed to demand justice against their oppressors.

From Protest to Politics is an essay by Bayard Rustin for the February 1965 issue of Commentary magazine. In this essay, Bayard Rustin stated that the civil rights movement needed to transition from street protests to coalition building. Rustin argued that since African Americans are a minority of the American population, they need to join in a coalition with labor unions and other progressives to achieve their goals of economic and political equality.

The Ballot or the Bullet is a speech Malcolm X delivered on April 3, 1964. Malcolm warns that if African Americans are not granted civil rights after voting a Democrat to power, then that shows the inefficacy of the electoral system for African Americans to achieving their just rights and may have to resort to more violent means to achieve their ends.

The Liberation of Our People is a speech that Angela Davis gave at a Black Panthers rally on November 12, 1969. Davis argues that black activists must join with Hispanic activists and antiwar activists to fight several fronts against American imperialism.

Below are some youtube videos of debates of different civil rights leaders.

Excerpts of a debate between Bayard Rustin and Malcolm X

A debate between James Farmer, Wyatt T. Walker and Malcolm X

About angelolopez

I’ve wanted to be an artist all my life. Since I was a child I’ve drawn on any scrap of paper I could get a hold of. When I went to San Jose State University, I became more exposed to the works of the great fine artists and illustrators. My college paintings were heavily influenced by the humorous illustrations of Peter De Seve, an illustrator for the New Yorker magazine. I also fell under the spell of the great muralists of the 1930s, especially Thomas Hart Benton and Diego Rivera. I graduated with a degree in Illustration. Angelo Lopez has had illustrations published in Tikkun Magazine, the Palo Alto Daily News and Z Magazine. From April 2008 to May 2011, Angelo's cartoons were regularly published in the Tri-City Voice, a weekly newspaper that covers the Fremont, Hayward, Milpitas, Neward, Sunol and Union City areas in California. He did a political webcomic starring his cartoon character Jasper for the progressive blogsite Everyday Citizen. Since December 2011, Angelo does a regular weekly political cartoon for the Philippine News Today, a Filipino American newspaper based in the San Francisco Bay Area. Angelo is a member of the Sunnyvale Art Club, and the Northern California chapter of the Society of Children's Book Writers and Illustrators. During the 1990s, he was a member of the part-timer workers SEIU unit in the city of Sunnyvale. Angelo won the 2013, 2015 and 2016 and 2018 Sigma Delta Chi award for editorial cartooning for newspapers with a circulation under 100,000. He has also won the 2016 RFK Book and Journalism Award for Editorial Cartoons. Angelo won first prize for the Best of the West contest in 2016 and third prize in 2017. Angelo is married to Lisa Reeber. They enjoy taking walks, watching movies and hanging out with their nieces.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s